So make it like pokemon got to catch em' all?

My thought is something more of an add on like with Ice imps being weak vs fire damage make it so you can upgrade it with another skill called "Iceblock Shield" that nulls one fire damage based attack but reduces all others by 60%

Not some evolution thing just skills that you can add on to make it more custom to you'r play style. Or even a full skill bar set up with in it's range. make it so that the pieces lvl up themselves. Tho leveling up Polymock peices won't get health for the peice, but they'll be able to learn new skills. This will make it more intresting.

I think it would be better if it were done like battle chess or something similar. The way it is currently set up, the pokemon like elements just arent all that fun to be honest imho. I did polymock just to get the skills and quests out of the way, but there wasnt much appeal after that for me.

If they were to redo it in a more board-game, strategy sort of way- that might be cooler- add that into the PvP element and it would add a different dimension to the challenge. Just my 2 cents.

Polymock pvp would be cool. Instead of just buying pieces though, how about players use a signet to capture dreatures that they have killed.

itd just be another trading card game...but still itd be great asura points and another excuse for more tourneys